Showing posts with label cart. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cart. Show all posts

30 November, 2013

Newegg Loses Patent Appeal

Patent trolls have been discussed, not only on this blog before, but all over the IP community in the last several years. Although steps are being taken to address this potential abuse of the patent system, until things are resolved these entities will still attempt to reap the benefits of their unused patents to make quick profits through settlement or litigation. One of the companies which has faced a wave of patent litigation of the past few years is the online retailer Newegg, having beaten Soverain, another patent troll company, on appeal after a tumultuous litigation process. It seems Newegg has yet to end its patent litigation chapter.

In the recent case against TQP Development, a company owned by Eric Spangenberg, Newegg faced a patent infringement case dealing with a patent invented by Michael Jones, which was since bought by TQP. The patent itself covers the usage of common encryption methods (SSL and RC4)  together to protect purchases online for example; although Mr. Jones did not invent the methods themselves.

This case is one which won't be fully cracked just yet
The jury in the case found that Newegg had indeed infringed the patent owned by TQP, awarding them with 2,3 million dollars in damages, and deciding that the patent held by the company was indeed valid. Although the decision has already rattled some cages, Newegg will without a doubt appeal the decision, as it has been their stance throughout all of their patent litigation history.

While the verdict itself is important, the motives behind litigation by not just TQP, but other similar companies as well, shows a blatant and open abuse of the current US patent system. The owner of  TQP Development Mr. Spangenberg openly states on his website for his company IPNav that he will "...[turn] idle IP assets into revenue streams", having sued a over 1600 companies in the last five years alone. Although clearly successful in his endeavors, Mr. Spangenberg's motives are highly questionable and only highlight a need for reform.

Newegg's Chief Legal Officer Lee Cheng took to Reddit and gave encouraging words over the verdit and previous ones, clearly further affirming their intentions to appeal the decision. Whether things will go better for them further down the line will remain to be seen, but at least this writer is optimistic.

Source: Ars Technica